Arnold and Dean successfully score the leading roles as Romeo & Romeo, leaving Raffy stuck in supporting role. Rome joins the production as sound designer at Jack's begruding request as Dean enlists Rome to keep Raffy away from Jack. Tua is convinced by Dean to share a private moment with Arnold.

Boston forcefully inserts himself back into Tua's life as Arnold promises Tua he'll help keep them apart. Dean finds out Jack ended up in rehab because of him. Rome takes Raffy with him whilst he DJs a party with Raffy taking his first step to truly ruin Dean, only to succeed in pushing Jack back towards his ex instead.

Rome chauffeurs Raffy to a talk show with his actress mother as Jack confirms he is still in love with Dean. Dean is determined to become a better person for Jack. Arnold is convinced by Tua to take on a modelling job for Boston after unintentionally leaving Tua in the friendzone again. Arnold is forced to begin confronting his feelings.

Arnold is still unsure of his feelings for Tua. When a sponsor for the play wants Raffy as Romeo instead of Dean, Jack comes up with a compromise. Tua gives Dean permission to post couples content online with Arnold. Rome warns Jack not to lead Raffy on as Boston turns his attention to the latter, causing Rome to lash out.

Dean and Arnold keep shooting fan-service content together, interfering with rehearsals and Jack's temper. Pete is encouraged to hit on Rome in front of Raffy. Timmy unknowingly throws a wrench into Tua's plan. Rome takes Raffy to a concert hosted by their seniors.

The theatre department are on their yearly outing as Jack and Dean reminisce about their beginning. Arnold makes Tua promise that he'll never lie to him again. Timmy realises someone is embezzling the production's sponsorship money and investigates. Rome and Raffy hook up in the woods despite knowing how Pete feels about Rome.